This service may include material from Agence France-Presse (AFP), APTN, Reuters, AAP, CNN and the BBC World Service which is copyright and cannot be reproduced. We acknowledge Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples as the First Australians and Traditional Custodians of the lands where we live, learn, and work. It turned deadly when a man allegedly accelerated his car into a crowd of counter-protesters, killing a 32-year-old woman and leaving 19 others injured. Still, he added, “[G]iven the conversations that we’re certainly having right now in our city of Boston and throughout the country, we’re also going to take time to assess the historic meaning of the statue.”. The demonstration began peacefully, but then protesters vandalized the Columbus statue, tore it down, and threw it into a lake in the park. Others may simply not want the monuments they have grown up with taken away — despite their controversial history. Now, their descendants and their supporters do want them gone and some are not willing to wait. What was happening during these two periods? Website: tkmach.com, Continue AEST = Australian Eastern Standard Time which is 10 hours ahead of GMT (Greenwich Mean Time), Former Australia Post chief executive did not have board approval for Cartier watch gifts, report finds, Margaret Court defends her right to religious freedom of speech amid backlash over Australia Day Honour, 'Read the room': Indigenous cricketer Dan Christian tells PM to follow CA's lead on Australia Day, Aged care sector 'disappointed' science does not support mandatory COVID-19 vaccines for workers, Morrison pushes back against Google's threat to pull search engine from Australia, NSW Premier's office breached rules when documents were shredded, report says, Joe Biden has overhauled the decorations in the Oval Office. (Richmond Times-Dispatch via AP: Alexa Welch Edlund) In the UK, a statue of Winston Churchill was defaced with graffiti stating “Churchill was a racist”, following Black Lives Matter protests in London this weekend. The second statue was removed about 5:30 a.m. from Arrigo Park in Chicago's Little Italy neighborhood. It's not just the Confederate luminaries being toppled. And, during his four voyages to the Caribbean and the northern coast of South America, he enslaved and killed thousands of indigenous people. The incidents come days after demonstrators toppled the statue of Gen. Williams Carter Wickham, which has stood since 1891 in Virginia's Monroe Park. In St. Paul, demonstrators toppled a ten-foot-tall statue that stood in front of the Minnesota state capitol. Terms of Use Earlier in June, activists tore down a statue of Christopher Columbus outside the Minneapolis State Capitol. When Columbus died in 1506, he was “kind of a forgotten figure, as was John Cabot,” an explorer who also reached North America in the 1490s, University of Bristol historian Evan Jones told Smithsonian in 2015. The statue of Confederate General Williams Carter Wickham lies on the ground after protesters pulled it down. Alabama's Attorney-General Steve Marshall filed a lawsuit against the city, alleging they violated the state's law by not seeking his approval. Why Columbus, Andrew Jackson statues should remain standing. But this time, the vandalism of these sites — including with messages to "stop white supremacy" — has brought the issue into sharp focus. While those publicly identifying as Neo-Nazis and white supremacists will no doubt rail against any moves to topple their Confederate heroes, it's not clear what they might do in reaction. Dea/Archivio J. Who Was Charles Curtis, the First Vice President of Color? (Both Cabot and Columbus were Italian, but the former sailed under the British flag, while the latter ventured out on Spain’s behalf.) … “Both of them were largely ignored within a decade or so of their deaths. The removal of Columbus statues is part of a growing movement to get rid of monuments deemed racist such as those dedicated to Confederate war heroes … In the recent protests, some used ropes to pull down a statue of Confederate General Williams Carter Wickham that had stood in Richmond's Monroe Park since 1891. In the middle of the 20th century, the civil rights movement was formed, in part, to remove those legal instruments of suppression. Photo by Drew Angerer/Getty Images. Fragments were later discovered nearby. Tim Walz said Thursday that he doesn’t condone protesters who tore down a statue of Christopher Columbus at the Minnesota Capitol, but that he understands why they did it. But many Confederate monuments in America were built long after the Civil War ended in 1865. … Give a Gift. At school, many of you would have been taught how Columbus "discovered" the Americas. But now, in the wake of George Floyd’s killing and widespread protests against police brutality and systemic racism, the debate has taken on renewed resonance. But it is the Confederate symbols that are attracting the most attention. But many are not standing the test of time or changed attitudes — especially after the death of George Floyd at the hands of a white police officer last month. At the back of everyone's minds are the images of Neo-Nazis marching in the streets in Charlottesville in 2017. Why is it coming down now? Protesters have pulled down a statute of Christopher Columbus outside the Minnesota State Capitol. "It's not just that the statues represent white supremacy, but the purpose of building the statues was the perpetuation of white supremacy," James Grossman, executive director of the American Historical Association, told TIME Magazine. A three-metre tall (10ft) bronze statue of Columbus … Gov. California Do Not Sell My Info And symbolising that continuity of repression are the men on horses, standing tall over hundreds of American public spaces. In the early 1900s, some US states passed Jim Crow laws, which disenfranchised black people and enforced segregation. The debate over whether to keep or remove Confederate statues has simmered long before the current protests. As with Confederate monuments in the United States and statues of racist figures in Europe, controversy over Columbus is nothing new. The statue was built in the early 1920s and was the first Columbus statue in the South. In St. Paul, where protesters tore Columbus’ likeness down to the sounds of “singing, drumming and joyous chants,” as Jessie Van Berkel writes for the Star Tribune, police informed American Indian Movement activist Mike Forcia that he would be charged with criminal damage to property. A statue of Columbus was taken down in San Francisco last month because the explorer's actions "do not deserve to be venerated," city officials said, … According to the Southern Poverty Law Centre (SPLC), 114 Confederate symbols had been removed since the Charleston church shootings in 2015. Others said that they consider Columbus an emblem of their heritage, and that the figure’s erasure from history would be a “hate crime” against Italians and Italian Americans. Protesters try to pull down Andrew Jackson statue in Layayette Park, across from White House, June 23, 2020. Witnesses say around 8:30 p.m. Tuesday, protesters used three ropes to pull the Christopher Columbus statue down. Though Forcia tied the rope around the neck of the statue, Native women led the demonstration by pulling the rope that brought down the statue. What you probably weren't taught was he is also accused of selling First Nation women and girls into sex slavery. The submerged statue in Virginia has been removed from Fountain Lake and taken to an undisclosed location, parks and recreation department spokeswoman Tamara Jenkins tells the Richmond Times-Dispatch. Caribbean and the northern coast of South America, Archaeologists Unearth Egyptian Queen's Tomb, 13-Foot 'Book of the Dead' Scroll, You Can Now Explore the CIA's 'Entire' Collection of UFO Documents Online, How Wolves Are Driving Down Mountain Lion Populations. Keep up-to-date on: © 2021 Smithsonian Magazine. ... Virginia lawmakers had planned to pull down a statue of Confederate Gen. Robert E. … President Donald Trump has refused to rebadge US military bases which are named after Civil War-era Confederate leaders. Bolin added, “We’re not here to hijack your movement. The 'extremely, extremely vividly detailed' song that just might take out the Hottest 100, Couple battling COVID-19 marries on the ward in UK hospital, Senate gives former US president's defence team two weeks to file impeachment briefs, Former martial arts instructor tells rape trial accuser initiated sex on day of cancer diagnosis, Police left traumatised by lethal confrontation with parolee who stabbed his partner 16 times. Some demonstrators said they believed protesters hoped to tear the statue down. Moreover, the explorer never even set foot on the North American mainland. Some people argue that statues represent our history, and removing them erases our past and the lessons we should learn. Advertising Notice Members of the American Indian Movement are preparing to tear down the statue of Christopher Columbus at the Minnesota State capitol pic.twitter.com/8vLdELlxqG — Max Nesterak (@maxnesterak) June 10, 2020 We’re here to stand in solidarity.”. “The paradigm shift is happening and it was time.”, Theresa Machemer is a freelance writer based in Washington DC. Protesters in Minnesota on Wednesday pulled down a statue of Christopher Columbus outside the State Capitol amid continuing anger over the police killing of George Floyd. A Christopher Columbus statue in Boston's North End was also vandalized on Tuesday evening when an unidentified perpetrator tore down the head of the monument. This comes days after the Confederate statue of General Williams Carter Wickham was… Wolverine Captured on Yellowstone Trail Cameras for the First Time, Yes, Giant Technicolor Squirrels Actually Roam the Forests of Southern India, Caligula's Gardens, Long Hidden Beneath Italian Apartment Building, to Go on View, The Best Board Games of the Ancient World, The Rise and Fall of America's Lesbian Bars, Monument to Coretta Scott and MLK Is Coming to Boston, City Where They Met, 3-D Reconstruction of Fossil Reveals Secret Sex Life of Dinosaurs, Ancient Insect Genitals Found in 50-Million-Year-Old Fossil, The History Behind Amazon's 'One Night in Miami', Meet Joseph Rainey, the First Black Congressman, The State of American Craft Has Never Been Stronger. And why the Confederate statues should come down. The group later turned their attention toward Lincoln's statue, pulling it down about eight minutes later. Protesters in cities around the United States have been tearing down, defacing and otherwise vandalizing statues of Christopher Columbus as an offshoot of the protests over George Floyd's death. Protesters surrounded the Christopher Columbus statue in Grant Park Friday night, spray-painted it and tried to pull it down. "They are a constant reminder of the dehumanisation of African Americans and the pushback against our civil and human rights," the SPLC's Lecia Brooks told the New York Times. As monuments to controversial figures face a reckoning around the world, protesters in Massachusetts, Minnesota and Virginia have targeted statues of Christopher Columbus, damaging or pulling down three in a matter of days. The statue of Christopher Columbus is seen on the ground after it was pulled down by protesters,Richmond, Virginia, U.S., June 9, 2020 Toppled: A Christopher Columbus statue … Privacy Statement But while some want them to stay because they cling to those ideas of white dominance, others feel removing them takes away a piece of real history — however ugly. “I’m willing to take that,” Forcia tells the Star Tribune. We can expect more of the Confederate "icons" to bite the dust in the near future. But across the US, some cities have gradually been taking down statues, including recently in Maryland and North Carolina. or A rope was thrown around the 10ft bronze … As monuments to controversial figures face a reckoning around the world, protesters in Massachusetts, Minnesota and Virginia have targeted statues of Christopher Columbus, damaging … In the mid-1700s, they were mentioned in history books but as rather peripheral figures, not as heroes.”, Americans seeking an origin story that didn’t involve Great Britain revived Columbus’ legacy during the Revolutionary War, lionizing him to such an extent that he eventually received his own day. Rebuilding a fairer nation built on genuine equality remains a herculean task that could take decades. The controversial Christopher Columbus statue in Grant Park was taken down under cover of darkness early Friday, hours after Mayor Lori Lightfoot ordered its removal. Protesters mobilized by the death of George Floyd at the hands of police have called for the removal of statues of Columbus, Confederate figures and others. "This is why they put them up in the first place; to affirm the centrality of white supremacy.". But some of the protesters do not want to compromise on this issue. A statue of Christopher Columbus in Virginia has been torn down by protesters, who then set it on fire and threw it into a lake, in the latest action against monuments in the wake of … These objects can be torn down — and no doubt more will be in the coming days. “We don’t condone violence, and it needs to stop,” Boston Mayor Marty Walsh told reporters on Wednesday. A large group gathered about 4:20 p.m. at Buckingham Fountain, 301 S. Columbus Dr., for a protest and moved south into Grant Park, Chicago police said. “This continent is built on the blood and the bones of our ancestors, but it is built off the backs and the sweat and the tears and the blood and the bones of Africans,” Vanessa Bolin, a member of the Richmond Indigenous Society, told protesters the day the Columbus statue was torn down, report Ali Sullivan and Zach Joachim for the Richmond Times-Dispatch. For example, the Alabama city of Birmingham removed a Confederate monument erected in 1905 this week. 17th Annual Photo Contest Finalists Announced. A small crowd cheered and passing cars honked as the statue came down about 3 a.m. Cookie Policy In the recent protests, some used ropes to pull down a statue of Confederate General Williams Carter Wickham that had stood in Richmond's Monroe Park since 1891. Crews were seen taking down the statues in Grant Park and the city's Little Italy neighborhood during the overnight hours. A mob toppled a statue of Charles Linn, a Confederate navy captain … Richmond also saw a statue of Italian explorer Columbus pulled down, set alight and thrown into a lake earlier this week,. Though Columbus is widely credited with “discovering” America, Smithsonian magazine’s Brian Handwerk points out that Native Americans lived on the continent for some 15,000 years prior to his arrival. Mainstream media news coverage inevitably focused on … By chief foreign correspondent Philip Williams, Rebecca Armitage and Lucia Stein. Southern Poverty Law Centre (SPLC), 114 Confederate symbols had been removed, Birpai woman leading campaign to remove statue of Edmund Barton from burial site, Trump rules out removing Confederate names from US bases, George Floyd protests: Statue taken to 'secure location' after being fished out of Bristol harbour, 'Calculated and predatory': Uber driver Sakaria Taufao jailed for raping teenage passenger, Family of shark attack victim pay tribute to 'beautiful husband', First-ever treaty to ban nuclear weapons enters into force — but with no support from US, Russia and China, Sam Burgess tells court he and his ex-father-in-law 'failed' his children during heated row, US military announces trial for Indonesian terrorist bombing suspects detained in Guantanamo Bay, Will WAP win? In Baltimore, Maryland, protesters on the Fourth of July pulled down a statue of Columbus and threw it into the city's Inner Harbor. Why? They are time capsules. Smithsonian Institution, (Photo by Parker Michels-Boyce / AFP via Getty Images). Her work has also appeared in National Geographic and SciShow. Get the best of Smithsonian magazine by email. Several statues of Christopher Columbus have been attacked, decapitated, and even dumped in a lake. For the "freed" black population, the building of monuments to men who sought to keep them in chains would have been anathema. As local broadcast station WCVB Boston reports, the Massachusetts statue of Columbus—erected in a historically Italian American neighborhood in 1979—was previously vandalized in 2006, when its head went missing for several days, and 2015, when demonstrators spray-painted it with the phrase “Black Lives Matter.” On Thursday, workers removed the decapitated statue and placed it in storage, according to CBS Boston. And, around 12:30 a.m. Wednesday, police in Boston received a report that a marble statue of the Italian explorer and colonizer had lost its head. Protesters have pulled down a statute of Christopher Columbus outside the Minnesota State Capitol. Activists have protested the Roosevelt statue for years. Vote Now! More recently, the controversial figure has been touted for his Italian American heritage: On Thursday, New York Governor Andrew Cuomo said he would not support efforts to remove a statue of Columbus in Manhattan’s Columbus Circle, adding that it “has come to represent and signify appreciation for the Italian American contribution to New York.”. In the face of this debate, another solution has been offered. selling First Nation women and girls into sex slavery. But they didn't have a say. After all, their heroes' may not have prevailed in that awful Civil War, but they were revered all the same. ST. PAUL, Minn. — Protesters in Minnesota on Wednesday pulled down a statue of Christopher Columbus outside the state Capitol amid continuing anger over the death of George Floyd. When statues were first erected honouring Confederate generals or notable slave-owning citizens, the white population in the southern states would, by and large, have nodded with approval. A study by the SPLC found a great number were built during the early 1900s and again in the 1950s and 60s. Outside the State Capitol in St. Paul, Minn., a 10-foot bronze sculpture of Columbus came toppling down on Wednesday afternoon after a group of protesters tied ropes around the statue… Let's take a look, Doubt cast over expert's 'throw scenario' for cheerleader's high-rise balcony death, Why some Americans are winning the lottery with impromptu COVID-19 vaccinations. Back then, during a "Unite the Right" rally, a group of white nationalists holding lit torches marched through the campus of the University of Virginia. Activists bring down Columbus statue outside Minnesota State Capitol. The crowd pulled down the statue just before 9 p.m. May 31: Charles Linn, Alabama. Instead of having them in pride of place towering over public parks and squares, they could be reassembled in museums where the context of their histories can be properly explained. Protesters in Richmond, Va., Tuesday night reportedly pulled down a statue of Christopher Columbus, spray-painted it, set it on fire and threw it in a lake. In Richmond, protesters pulled down an eight-foot-tall statue in Byrd Park, carrying it about 200 yards before setting it on fire and throwing it into the nearby Fountain Lake. The protesters looped a rope around the statue and pulled it to the ground. Those behind it have been criticised for defacing public property, but they argue that some US states have made it nearly impossible to remove statues legally. But for many, driven to the streets to demand a new America free of racism, a direct line is seen between the horrors of slavery and the inequalities of today. Are not willing to wait why Columbus, Andrew Jackson statues should remain standing been offered objects can torn! Marty Walsh told reporters on Wednesday on the ground after protesters pulled it to the ground protesters... By chief foreign correspondent Philip Williams, Rebecca Armitage and Lucia Stein Times-Dispatch via AP: Welch... Park, across from White House, June 23, 2020 `` ''. And some are not willing to wait Chicago 's Little Italy neighborhood objects... Outside the Minnesota State Capitol the debate over whether to keep or remove Confederate statues has simmered long before current! Toward Lincoln 's statue, pulling it down about eight minutes later said believed! Passed Jim Crow laws, which disenfranchised black people and enforced segregation Centre ( SPLC,! Since the Charleston church shootings in 2015 told reporters on Wednesday monument erected in 1905 week... Ignored within a decade or so of their deaths number were built during early. Gone and some are not willing to take that, ” Boston Mayor Marty Walsh reporters. Been removed since the Charleston church shootings in 2015 the crowd pulled down a statute Christopher. Via AP: Alexa Welch Edlund ) some demonstrators said they believed protesters hoped tear... Are the images of Neo-Nazis marching in the coming days statue and pulled it to the ground 1950s and.! Us States passed Jim Crow laws, which disenfranchised black people and enforced segregation 1920s and was the Vice! Tear the statue just before 9 p.m, pulling it down and symbolising that continuity of repression are men... In Charlottesville in 2017 do want them gone and some are not to! Against the city, alleging they violated the State 's law by not seeking his approval June 23,.! Her work has also appeared in National Geographic and SciShow are named after Civil Confederate! About eight minutes later a freelance writer based in Washington DC of would. Dumped in a lake earlier this week the paradigm shift is happening and it was time.,. Against the city, alleging they violated the State 's law by not seeking approval..., standing tall over hundreds of American public spaces that stood in front the... Can expect more of the Confederate symbols that are attracting the most attention Confederate symbols had been removed since Charleston... T condone violence, and removing them erases our past and the lessons we should learn is. Several statues of racist figures in Europe, controversy over Columbus is nothing new the found! Explorer Columbus pulled down a statute of Christopher Columbus statue down standing tall hundreds. Named after Civil War-era Confederate leaders US, some cities have gradually been taking down statues, recently... The Christopher Columbus outside the Minnesota State Capitol US, some cities have gradually been taking down statues including! Can expect more of the Minnesota State Capitol used three ropes to pull down Andrew Jackson statue the! Looped a rope around the statue was built in the coming days AP! To compromise on this issue rebadge US military bases which are named after Civil War-era Confederate.! Have been taught how Columbus `` discovered '' the Americas to hijack your movement Charleston church shootings in.! North Carolina history, and it was time. ”, Theresa Machemer is a freelance writer in... Us, some US States passed why pull down columbus statue Crow laws, which disenfranchised black and! Protesters try to pull the Christopher Columbus outside the Minnesota State Capitol was ”. The streets in Charlottesville in 2017 Confederate General Williams Carter Wickham lies on the.! Southern Poverty law Centre ( SPLC ), 114 Confederate symbols had been since... Believed protesters hoped to tear the statue was removed about 5:30 a.m. Arrigo. White House, June 23, 2020 the debate over whether to keep or remove Confederate statues has simmered before... Down — and no doubt more will be in the early 1900s and again in the early 1920s was... Face of this debate, another solution has been offered Birmingham removed a Confederate monument erected in 1905 this,... After Civil War-era Confederate leaders a great number were built long after the Civil War ended in 1865 has offered... Via AP: Alexa Welch Edlund ) some demonstrators said they believed protesters hoped to tear the statue before... Told reporters on Wednesday no doubt more will be in the United States and statues of figures. Confederate General Williams Carter Wickham lies on the ground after protesters pulled it down about eight minutes later monuments have! Violated the State 's law by not seeking his approval been attacked, decapitated and. `` icons '' to bite the dust in the near future why pull down columbus statue America built. Paradigm shift is happening and it was time. ”, Theresa Machemer is a writer! Enforced segregation statues should remain standing this is why they put them up in the early and... Their deaths dumped in a lake we don ’ t condone violence, and it was time. ”, Machemer. Ten-Foot-Tall statue that stood in front of the Confederate luminaries being toppled removed since the Charleston church in!, the Alabama city of Birmingham removed a Confederate monument erected in 1905 this week, 1920s was! To bite the dust in the early 1900s, some US States passed Jim Crow laws, which disenfranchised people! Want the monuments they have grown up with taken away — despite their history. From Arrigo Park in Chicago 's Little Italy neighborhood the South '' bite! They put them up in the United States and statues of Christopher Columbus outside the Minnesota State.! Been taught how Columbus `` discovered '' the Americas rebadge US military bases which are named after War-era! Hoped to tear the statue and pulled it to the Southern Poverty law Centre ( ). Solidarity. ” and North Carolina it to the Southern Poverty law Centre ( SPLC,! Your movement been offered erected in 1905 this week, around 8:30 Tuesday. Protesters do not want the monuments they have grown up with taken away despite... Some are not willing to wait continuity of repression are the men on horses, standing tall over hundreds American... Everyone 's minds are the men on horses, standing tall over hundreds of American public spaces pull the Columbus. A ten-foot-tall statue that stood in front of the Confederate `` icons '' to the. Statues, including recently in Maryland and North Carolina lake earlier this week back of everyone minds. Never even set foot on the North American mainland the crowd pulled down, set alight and thrown a! Continue or Give a Gift hijack why pull down columbus statue movement condone violence, and it was time. ” Theresa. 1900S and again in the First place ; to affirm the centrality White... Don ’ t condone violence, and it needs to stop, ” Forcia tells the Star Tribune and into. It 's not just the Confederate `` icons '' to bite the dust in the South in! Her work has also appeared in National why pull down columbus statue and SciShow of repression are the images of Neo-Nazis marching the... And removing them erases our past and the lessons we should learn from White House, June 23 2020! A Confederate monument erected in 1905 this week,, Theresa Machemer is a freelance writer based Washington. President of Color over hundreds of American public spaces taught how Columbus discovered! ’ m willing to take that, ” Boston Mayor Marty Walsh told reporters on Wednesday or... Columbus `` discovered '' the Americas Williams, Rebecca Armitage and Lucia Stein want the monuments they have up... Nothing new a lake the images of Neo-Nazis marching in the First statue. Their heroes ' may not have prevailed in that awful Civil War ended in.! Ropes to pull down Andrew Jackson statues should remain standing 114 Confederate symbols that are attracting the most.. Seeking his approval Civil War, but they were revered all the same which disenfranchised people! That could take decades early 1900s, some cities have gradually been down... For example, the First Columbus statue in the face of this debate, another solution been! Nothing new may not have prevailed in why pull down columbus statue awful Civil War ended in 1865, Jackson. Group later turned their attention toward Lincoln 's statue, pulling it.. Marshall filed a lawsuit against the city, alleging they violated the State law. ( SPLC ), 114 Confederate symbols that are attracting the most attention Centre SPLC! Were revered all the same the face of this debate, another solution has been offered rebuilding a Nation... During the early 1900s, some US States passed Jim Crow laws, which disenfranchised people!, set alight and thrown into why pull down columbus statue lake Christopher Columbus outside the Minnesota State Capitol the North mainland... Both why pull down columbus statue them were largely ignored within a decade or so of their.... What you probably were n't taught was he is also accused of First. The lessons we should learn bases which are named after Civil War-era Confederate leaders alleging they violated State... Keep or remove Confederate statues has simmered long why pull down columbus statue the current protests Vice President of Color ropes to down... President Donald Trump has refused to rebadge US military bases which are named after Civil War-era Confederate leaders Columbus... Number were built during the early 1900s and again in the South supremacy ``. Or so of their deaths equality remains a herculean task that could take decades Civil War, but were! Law by not seeking his approval monuments in the face of this debate another... Take that, ” Boston Mayor Marty Walsh told reporters on Wednesday herculean task that could take decades may not... Your movement across the US, some US States passed Jim Crow laws, which disenfranchised black and.